Free shipping on all orders over $50

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Not sure where to start? Check out some of our favorites!

Staff Favorites
18+ only

Please verify your age

You must be 18 years of age or older to enter.

Exit

By entering you are agreeing that you are at least 18 years of age or older.

Butt Plugs

Designed with a tapered tip for easy insertion and a flared base or string for safety, butt plugs come with a variety of features such as vibration, remote control, inflation, or just something with some bling. Whether you're a beginner seeking added stimulation or an experienced user wanting more intense orgasms, you're sure to find the plug for you.

Advanced Play Anal Toys
Advanced Play Anal Toys (29)
Anal Beads
Anal Beads (117)
Anal Lube
Anal Lube (58)
Inflatable Anal Toys
Inflatable Anal Toys (60)
Butt Plugs
Butt Plugs (861)
Douches and Enemas
Douches and Enemas (113)
Prostate Toys
Prostate Toys (174)
Beginner-Friendly Anal Toys
Beginner-Friendly Anal Toys (37)

861 Results

Clear all

861 Results

Clear all
Tailz Fox Tail Anal Plug - Gray
Tailz Fox Tail Anal Plug - Gray
TAILZ

Tailz Fox Tail Anal Plug

$64.99

$64.99

Tailz Bunny Tail Anal Plug - White
Tailz Bunny Tail Anal Plug - White
New
TAILZ

Tailz Bunny Tail Anal Plug

$36.99

$36.99

Tailz Blondie's Pony Tail Butt Plug - Black
Tailz Blondie's Pony Tail Butt Plug - Black
TAILZ

Tailz Blondie's Pony Tail Butt Plug

$42.99

$42.99

Zeus Electro-Spread 64x Vibrating and E-Stim Silicone Rechargeable Butt Plug with Remote Control - Black
Zeus Electro-Spread 64x Vibrating and E-Stim Silicone Rechargeable Butt Plug with Remote Control - Black
Zeus Electrosex

Zeus Electro-Spread 64x Vibrating and E-Stim Silicone Rechargeable Butt Plug with Remote Control

$144.99

$144.99

Swell Inflatable Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Missile Anal Plug - Black
Swell Inflatable Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Missile Anal Plug - Black
New
SWELL

Swell Inflatable Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Missile Anal Plug

$129.99

$129.99

Platinum Premium Silicone - The Stretch - Medium Anal Expander Plug - Black
Platinum Premium Silicone - The Stretch - Medium Anal Expander Plug - Black
Platinum Premium Silicone

Platinum Premium Silicone - The Stretch - Medium Anal Expander Plug

$74.99

$74.99

Zero Tolerance Blue Oasis Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Anal Plug - Blue
Zero Tolerance Blue Oasis Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Anal Plug - Blue
Zero Tolerance

Zero Tolerance Blue Oasis Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Anal Plug

$46.99

$46.99

Platinum Premium Silicone - The Li'l End Anal Plug - Charcoal/Grey
Platinum Premium Silicone - The Li'l End Anal Plug - Charcoal/Grey
Platinum Premium Silicone

Platinum Premium Silicone - The Li'l End Anal Plug

$29.99

$29.99

Ouch! Butt Plug with Cock Ring Silicone - Glow In The Dark/Green
Ouch! Butt Plug with Cock Ring Silicone - Glow In The Dark/Green
Ouch!

Ouch! Butt Plug with Cock Ring Silicone

$54.99

$54.99

Zero Tolerance Reach Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug - Blue
Zero Tolerance Reach Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug - Blue
Zero Tolerance

Zero Tolerance Reach Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug

$59.99

$59.99

Ouch! Beads Butt Plug with Cock Ring Silicone - Glow In The Dark/Green
Ouch! Beads Butt Plug with Cock Ring Silicone - Glow In The Dark/Green
Ouch!

Ouch! Beads Butt Plug with Cock Ring Silicone

$54.99

$54.99

Zero Tolerance Wicked Twister Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Butt Plug - Purple
Zero Tolerance Wicked Twister Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Butt Plug - Purple
Zero Tolerance

Zero Tolerance Wicked Twister Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Butt Plug

$84.99

$84.99

Zero Tolerance Titan Anal Plug - Black
Zero Tolerance Titan Anal Plug - Black
Zero Tolerance

Zero Tolerance Titan Anal Plug

$89.99

$89.99

Anal Fantasy Elite Gyro-Milk Pro with Remote Control - Black
Anal Fantasy Elite Gyro-Milk Pro with Remote Control - Black
Anal Fantasy Elite

Anal Fantasy Elite Gyro-Milk Pro with Remote Control

$134.99

$134.99

Anal Fantasy Elite Ass-Gasm Gyro-Milk Pro with Remote Control - Black
Anal Fantasy Elite Ass-Gasm Gyro-Milk Pro with Remote Control - Black
Anal Fantasy Elite

Anal Fantasy Elite Ass-Gasm Gyro-Milk Pro with Remote Control

$134.99

$134.99

Satisfyer Lolli-Plug 2 Silicone Beaded Anal Plug - Green
Satisfyer Lolli-Plug 2 Silicone Beaded Anal Plug - Green
Satisfyer

Satisfyer Lolli-Plug 2 Silicone Beaded Anal Plug

$64.99

$64.99

Satisfyer Game Changer Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug - Black
Satisfyer Game Changer Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug - Black
Satisfyer

Satisfyer Game Changer Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug

$74.99

$74.99

Jimmyjane Dia Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug - Blue
Jimmyjane Dia Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug - Blue
Jimmyjane

Jimmyjane Dia Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug

$124.99

$124.99

Thunder Plug Butt Slider 7x Sliding Ring Silicone Rechargeable Missle Plug with Remote Control - Black
Thunder Plug Butt Slider 7x Sliding Ring Silicone Rechargeable Missle Plug with Remote Control - Black
Thunder Plugs

Thunder Plug Butt Slider 7x Sliding Ring Silicone Rechargeable Missle Plug with Remote Control

$174.99

$174.99

Anal Stud Silicone Probe - Black - 5.5in
Anal Stud Silicone Probe - Black - 5.5in
Anal

Anal Stud Silicone Probe

$39.99

$39.99

Rouge Stainless Steel Penis Plug Set with Handle - Silver
Rouge Stainless Steel Penis Plug Set with Handle - Silver
Rouge

Rouge Stainless Steel Penis Plug Set with Handle

$169.99

$169.99

Envy Toys Thumbs Up Remote Controlled Rechargeable Silicone P-Spot Vibrator and Dual Stamina Ring - Black
Envy Toys Thumbs Up Remote Controlled Rechargeable Silicone P-Spot Vibrator and Dual Stamina Ring - Black
Envy Toys

Envy Toys Thumbs Up Remote Controlled Rechargeable Silicone P-Spot Vibrator and Dual Stamina Ring

$129.99

$129.99

Envy Toys Enticer Remote Controlled Rechargeable Silicone Expander Butt Plug - Black
Envy Toys Enticer Remote Controlled Rechargeable Silicone Expander Butt Plug - Black
Envy Toys

Envy Toys Enticer Remote Controlled Rechargeable Silicone Expander Butt Plug

$119.99

$119.99

Strict Male Chastity Harness with Silicone Anal Plug - Black
Strict Male Chastity Harness with Silicone Anal Plug - Black
STRICT

Strict Male Chastity Harness with Silicone Anal Plug

$64.99

$64.99

Stainless Steel Shower Penis Plug
Stainless Steel Shower Penis Plug
Rouge

Stainless Steel Shower Penis Plug

$54.99

$54.99

Rouge Stainless Steel Butt Plug Tail with Real Fur - Black - Medium
Rouge

Rouge Stainless Steel Butt Plug Tail with Real Fur

$82.99

$82.99

Rouge Stainless Steel Anal Passion Plug - Metal
Rouge

Rouge Stainless Steel Anal Passion Plug

$62.99

$62.99

Rouge Smooth Stainless Steel Anal Plug - Medium - Yellow Jewel - Yellow
Rouge

Rouge Smooth Stainless Steel Anal Plug - Medium - Yellow Jewel

$79.99

$79.99

Rouge Smooth Stainless Steel Anal Plug - Medium - Red Jewel - Red
Rouge

Rouge Smooth Stainless Steel Anal Plug - Medium - Red Jewel

$79.99

$79.99

Rouge Smooth Stainless Steel Anal Plug - Clear Jewel - Large
Rouge Smooth Stainless Steel Anal Plug - Clear Jewel - Large
Rouge

Rouge Smooth Stainless Steel Anal Plug

from $56.99

from $56.99

Nu Sensuelle Mini-Plug Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Plug - Black
Nu Sensuelle Mini-Plug Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Plug - Black
Nu Sensuelle

Nu Sensuelle Mini-Plug Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Plug

$59.99

$59.99

Rouge Ribbed Stainless Steel Anal Plug with Handle
Rouge

Rouge Ribbed Stainless Steel Anal Plug with Handle

$84.99

$84.99

Rouge Fish Tail Stainless Steel Anal Plug Probe - Clear Jewel - Large
Rouge Fish Tail Stainless Steel Anal Plug Probe - Clear Jewel - Medium
Rouge

Rouge Fish Tail Stainless Steel Anal Plug Probe

from $64.99

from $64.99

Nexus Beat Thumping Rechargeable Silicone Butt Plug with Remote Control - Black
Nexus Beat Thumping Rechargeable Silicone Butt Plug with Remote Control - Black
Nexus

Nexus Beat Thumping Rechargeable Silicone Butt Plug with Remote Control

$139.99

$139.99

Nexus Tornado Silicone Rechargeable Remote Rotating Plug with Cock and Ball Rings - Black
Nexus Tornado Silicone Rechargeable Remote Rotating Plug with Cock and Ball Rings - Black
Nexus

Nexus Tornado Silicone Rechargeable Remote Rotating Plug with Cock and Ball Rings

$129.99

$129.99

Nexus Tornado Rechargeable Silicone Rotating Butt Plug with Remote - Black - Medium
Nexus Tornado Rechargeable Silicone Rotating Butt Plug with Remote - Black - Medium
Nexus

Nexus Tornado Rechargeable Silicone Rotating Butt Plug with Remote

$69.99

$69.99

Nexus Simul8 Rechargeable Silicone Prostate Edition Vibrating Dual Motor Anal Cock and Ball - Black
Nexus Simul8 Rechargeable Silicone Prostate Edition Vibrating Dual Motor Anal Cock and Ball - Black
Nexus

Nexus Simul8 Rechargeable Silicone Prostate Edition Vibrating Dual Motor Anal Cock and Ball

$119.99

$119.99

WhipSmart Fluffy Bunny Metal Plug with Tail - Metal/Pink - 2.5in
WhipSmart Fluffy Bunny Metal Plug with Tail - Metal/Pink - 2.5in
8% off
Whipsmart

WhipSmart Fluffy Bunny Metal Plug with Tail

$37.99 $34.99

$37.99 $34.99

WhipSmart Metal Plug with 14in Indigo Fox Tail - Black/Metal - 2.5in
WhipSmart Metal Plug with 14in Indigo Fox Tail - Black/Metal - 2.5in
Whipsmart

WhipSmart Metal Plug with 14in Indigo Fox Tail

$59.99

$59.99

WhipSmart Metal Plug with 14in Fox Tail - Brown/Metal - 2.5in
WhipSmart Metal Plug with 14in Fox Tail - Brown/Metal - 2.5in
Whipsmart

WhipSmart Metal Plug with 14in Fox Tail

$59.99

$59.99

WhipSmart Silicone Plug 4in with Pony Tail - Black
WhipSmart Silicone Plug 4in with Pony Tail - Black
Whipsmart

WhipSmart Silicone Plug 4in with Pony Tail

$64.99

$64.99

WhipSmart Foxtail Furry 16in Playset with Silicone Butt Plug - Black/Grey - 4.5in
WhipSmart Foxtail Furry 16in Playset with Silicone Butt Plug - Black/Grey - 4.5in
7% off
Whipsmart

WhipSmart Foxtail Furry 16in Playset with Silicone Butt Plug

$74.99 $69.99

$74.99 $69.99

Nexus Duo Rechargeable Silicone Remote Control Beginner Butt Plug - Black - Small
Nexus Duo Rechargeable Silicone Remote Control Beginner Butt Plug - Black - Small
Nexus

Nexus Duo Rechargeable Silicone Remote Control Beginner Butt Plug

$114.99

$114.99

WhipSmart Glass Butt Plug with Curved Base - Clear/Glow In The Dark - 3.5in
WhipSmart Glass Butt Plug with Curved Base - Clear/Glow In The Dark - 3.5in
Whipsmart

WhipSmart Glass Butt Plug with Curved Base

$52.99

$52.99

WhipSmart Glass Butt Plug with Flat Base - Clear/Glow In The Dark - 3.5in
WhipSmart Glass Butt Plug with Flat Base - Clear/Glow In The Dark - 3.5in
Whipsmart

WhipSmart Glass Butt Plug with Flat Base

$44.99

$44.99

Nexus Butt Plug Trio Silicone Butt Plugs - Black - 3 Pieces
Nexus Butt Plug Trio Silicone Butt Plugs - Black - 3 Pieces
Nexus

Nexus Butt Plug Trio Silicone Butt Plugs

$89.99

$89.99

WhipSmart Glow In The Dark Silicone Anal Training Kit - Glow In The Dark/Green - 3 Piece
WhipSmart Glow In The Dark Silicone Anal Training Kit - Glow In The Dark/Green - 3 Piece
Whipsmart

WhipSmart Glow In The Dark Silicone Anal Training Kit

$64.99

$64.99

Nexus Ace Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Butt Plug with Remote Control - Black - Small
Nexus Ace Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Butt Plug with Remote Control - Black - Small
Nexus

Nexus Ace Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Butt Plug with Remote Control

from $114.99

from $114.99

Petite Sensations Teazer Silicone Vibrating Anal Stimulator - Purple
Petite Sensations Teazer Silicone Vibrating Anal Stimulator - Purple
Rocks Off

Petite Sensations Teazer Silicone Vibrating Anal Stimulator

$49.99

$49.99

Petite Sensations Teazer Silicone Anal Stimulator - Black
Petite Sensations Teazer Silicone Anal Stimulator - Black
Rocks Off

Petite Sensations Teazer Silicone Anal Stimulator

$39.99

$39.99

Load more